Agenda item
Deferred Items
To consider the following applications:
Def Item 1 – 21/504571/FULL Greystone, Bannister Hill, Borden
Tabled Papers added 8 December 2021.
Additional Information which might be referred to added 8 December 2021.
Def Item 2 – 21/501740/FULL Hill Farm, Rook Lane, Keycol Hill, Bobbing
Additional Information which might be referred to added 8 December 2021.
Members of the public are advised to confirm with Planning Services prior to the meeting that the applications will be considered at this meeting.
Requests to speak on these items must be registered with Democratic Services (democraticservices@swale.gov.uk or call us on 01795 417328) by noon on Wednesday 8 December 2021.
Minutes:
Reports shown in previous Minutes as being deferred from that Meeting
Def Item 1 REFERENCE NO - 21/504571/FULL |
||
APPLICATION PROPOSAL Demolition of existing property and erection of 2no. five bedroom dwellings with associated parking and private amenity space as amended by drawing no's. 21.29_PL_11 Rev A, 21.29_PL_12 Rev B, 21.29_PL13 Rev B, 21.29_PL14 Rev A and 21.29_PL_20. |
||
ADDRESSGreystone Bannister Hill Borden ME9 8HU |
||
WARD Borden And Grove Park |
PARISH/TOWN COUNCILBorden |
APPLICANT Ashbyrne Homes Ltd AGENT Kent Design Partnership |
This item was withdrawn from the agenda and the above application was considered under the Planning Working Group.
DEF ITEM 2 REFERENCE NO - 21/501740/FULL |
||
APPLICATION PROPOSAL Erection of a nurse accommodation building, car park and outdoor event space for Demelza. Erection of 30 private residential dwellings, together with associated access, parking, highway works, drainage and landscaping. |
||
ADDRESSLand At Hill Farm Rook Lane Keycol Hill Bobbing Kent |
||
WARD Bobbing, Iwade And Lower Halstow |
PARISH/TOWN COUNCILBobbing |
APPLICANT Esquire Developments & Demelza Hospice Care For Children AGENT DHA Planning |
The Senior Planning Officer introduced the application which had previously been considered by the Planning Committee in October 2021. She explained that it was an enabling development to fund Demelza House hospice facilities. The current application included revised developer contributions, with greater Section 106 contributions, additional housing and significant highway improvements. The Senior Planning Officer referred to paragraphs 3.22 to 3.27 of the report which outlined the benefits for the hospice.
Mr Andrew Wilford, the Agent, spoke in support of the application.
The Chairman moved the officer recommendation to approve the application and this was seconded by Councillor Ben J Martin.
A visiting Ward Member spoke against the application.
In the debate that followed, Members raised the following points:
· Welcomed the work carried out by the developer and officers which resulted in increased Section 106 Agreement contributions;
· disappointed with the lack of affordable housing on the site;
· this was over-intensive development and did not consider the site was large enough for 30 dwellings;
· the design of the housing was poor;
· concerned that the 2018 permission had commenced, despite viability arguments;
· three of the nurse units could be considered as affordable housing as key worker accommodation;
· welcomed the junction improvements;
· the air quality issues had now been addressed;
· the enabling aspect of the application outweighed the lack of affordable housing;
· the viability assessment indicated that affordable housing would not have been delivered; and
· the design was much better now.
A Member sought clarification on the 5-year housing supply and the Head of Planning Services advised that it was not currently possible to give a precise figure, but it was hoped this could be given before Christmas this year.
On being put to the vote, Councillor Mike Baldock requested that it be recorded that he voted against the application.
Resolved: That application 21/501740/FULL be approved subject to conditions (1) to (44) in the report and the completion of a suitably-worded Section 106 legal agreement, and with authority to amend the wording of the legal agreement and the planning conditions as reasonably required.
Supporting documents:
- Front Sheet, item 501. PDF 55 KB
- INDEX 9 December 2021, item 501. PDF 59 KB
- Def Item 1 Greystone, item 501. PDF 347 KB
- Def Item 1 APPENDIX 1, item 501. PDF 316 KB
- Tabled - Borden Parish Council comments, item 501. PDF 34 KB
- Tabled - Greystone Highway Review Update, item 501. PDF 829 KB
- Tabled - Hawkins, item 501. PDF 3 KB
- Tabled - Jenkins, item 501. PDF 6 KB
- Tabled - McEwan, item 501. PDF 9 KB
- Tabled - Meadows, item 501. PDF 12 KB
- Def item 1 - 1981 application, item 501. PDF 137 KB
- Def item 1 - Aerial photo with Local Plan boundaries on, item 501. PDF 2 MB
- Def item 1 - Aerial site location plan, item 501. PDF 3 MB
- Def item 1 - Block Plan amended, item 501. PDF 1 MB
- Def item 1 - CAR TRACKING PLAN K2149-BWP-XX-XX-DR-C-0601-P01, item 501. PDF 1 MB
- Def item 1 - Constraints Plan, item 501. PDF 119 KB
- Def item 1 - Existing property Greystone, item 501. PDF 242 KB
- Def item 1 - Existing Block Plan, item 501. PDF 1 MB
- Def item 1 - FIRE ENGINE TRACKING PLAN K2149-BWP-XX-XX-DR-C-0600-P01, item 501. PDF 242 KB
- Def item 1 - PLAN WITH GARAGE DIMENSIONS PLOT 3 21.29_PL_13_B_HT-C Plans and Elevations, item 501. PDF 576 KB
- Def item 1 - PLAN WITH GARAGE DIMENSIONS PLOT 421.29_PL_14_B_HT-D Plans and Elevations, item 501. PDF 617 KB
- Def item 1 - Plot 3 elevations and plans, item 501. PDF 440 KB
- Def item 1 - Plot 4 AMENDED elevations and plans, item 501. PDF 397 KB
- Def item 1 - REVISED and ANNOTATED Proposed Block Plan and Site Section A-A, item 501. PDF 2 MB
- Def item 1 - Site Location Plan, item 501. PDF 718 KB
- Def item 1 - Topographical Survey, item 501. PDF 466 KB
- Def Item 2 Hill Farm Rooks Lane, item 501. PDF 490 KB
- Def Item 2 APPENDIX 1, item 501. PDF 623 KB
- Def Item 2 APPENDIX 2, item 501. PDF 1 MB
- Def Item 2 APPENDIX 3, item 501. PDF 199 KB
- DEF ITEM 2 APPENDIX 4, item 501. PDF 219 KB
- DEF ITEM 2 APPENDIX 5, item 501. PDF 476 KB
- Def Item 2 APPENDIX 6, item 501. PDF 195 KB
- Def item 2 - 1. Briefing Document, item 501. PDF 7 MB
- Def item 2 - 2. Proposed Site Layout Plan (Coloured), item 501. PDF 6 MB
- Def item 2 - 3. Proposed Site Layout Plan (B&W), item 501. PDF 918 KB
- Def item 2 - 4. Proposed Street Elevations, item 501. PDF 3 MB
- Def item 2 - 5. Proposed CGI Views, item 501. PDF 3 MB
- Def item 2 - 6. Landscape Proposals (indicative), item 501. PDF 997 KB
- Def item 2 - 7. Proposed Nurse Accomodation, item 501. PDF 662 KB
- Def item 2 - 8. Proposed Site Plan - Housing Mix & Tenure Plan, item 501. PDF 1 MB
- Def item 2 - 9. Proposed Site Plan - Parking Strategy Plan, item 501. PDF 1 MB
- Def item 2 - 10. Proposed Site Plan - Area Plan, item 501. PDF 912 KB
- Def item 2 - 11. Proposed Access Plan, item 501. PDF 877 KB
- Def item 2 - 12. Proposed Highway Adoption Plan, item 501. PDF 884 KB
- Def item 2 - 13. Site Location Plan, item 501. PDF 281 KB
- Def item 2 - A2 Keycol Hill looking east, item 501. PDF 2 MB
- Def item 2 - Commencement of 2018 consent - Applicant Photo (1), item 501. PDF 1 MB
- Def item 2 - Commencement of 2018 consent - Applicant Photo (2), item 501. PDF 827 KB
- Def item 2 - Commencement of 2018 consent - Applicant Photo (3), item 501. PDF 1 MB
- Def item 2 - Commencement of 2018 consent - Applicant Photo (4), item 501. PDF 1 MB
- Def item 2 - Commencement of 2018 consent (1), item 501. PDF 1 MB
- Def item 2 - Commencement of 2018 consent (2), item 501. PDF 771 KB
- Def item 2 - Commencement of 2018 consent (3), item 501. PDF 1 MB
- Def item 2 - Commencement of 2018 consent (4), item 501. PDF 543 KB
- Def item 2 - Demelza access from Rook Lane, item 501. PDF 1 MB
- Def item 2 - Existing Bus Stop A2 Keycol Hill, item 501. PDF 1 MB
- Def item 2 - Existing Bus Stop and looking west A2 Keycol Hill, item 501. PDF 1 MB
- Def item 2 - Existing Junction A2 Keycol Hill & Rook Lane, item 501. PDF 1 MB
- Def item 2 - Existing Rook Lane towards A2 Keycol Hill, item 501. PDF 745 KB
- Def item 2 - Existing view from A2 Keycoll Hill and Rook Lane junction in background (May 2021), item 501. PDF 1 MB
- Def item 2 - Panoramic view from existing SUDs area looking north and east across the site, item 501. PDF 3 MB
- Def item 2 - Panoramic view from existing SUDs area, looking at southern part of site, and A2 Keycol Hill beyond the tree line, item 501. PDF 3 MB
- Def item 2 - Panoramic view from north-east of the site looking south and west, item 501. PDF 3 MB
- Def item 2 - Panoramic view from Rook Lane (opposite Demelza entrance) looking east, item 501. PDF 4 MB
- Def item 2 - Panoramic View from Rook Lane towards site(May 2021), item 501. PDF 4 MB
- Def item 2 - Robin Close (May 2021), item 501. PDF 1 MB
- Def item 2 - Rooks View (1) (May 2021), item 501. PDF 1 MB
- Def item 2 - Rooks View (2) (May 2021), item 501. PDF 1 MB
- Def item 2 - Rooks View, item 501. PDF 1 MB
- Def item 2 - Site - looking south towards A2 Keycol Hill, item 501. PDF 944 KB
- Def item 2 - Site - looking south-east towards dwellings to north of A2 Keycol Hill, item 501. PDF 692 KB
- Def item 2 - Site looking west towards Rooks View and Demelza, item 501. PDF 1 MB
- Def item 2 - Site looking west towards SUDs area, and dwellings on Rook Lane (Rooks View & Robin Close), item 501. PDF 962 KB
- Def item 2 - View from A2 Keycol Hill looking west towards site (2) (May 2021), item 501. PDF 2 MB
- Def item 2 - View from A2 Keycol Hill looking west towards site (May 2021), item 501. PDF 903 KB
- Def item 2 - View from Rook Lane looking south-east and south (May 2021), item 501. PDF 743 KB
- Def item 2 - View from Rook Lane to north of site, looking south, and south-east, item 501. PDF 547 KB
- Def item 2 - View from Rook Lane to north of site, looking south, item 501. PDF 701 KB